Inside Apple's top secret iPhone factory: Tech giant provides a glimpse of huge Chinese plant where 50,000 pink-jacketed staff are subjected to facial recognition, metal detectors and daily roll calls

在苹果公司绝密的iPhone装配工厂:科技巨头提供了这个巨大的中国工厂的一些缩影,这里有50000名身着粉红夹克的装配员工,要求每天做面部识别、金属探测、并点名
Simon Tomlinson for MailOnline

Rare access given inside Pegatron Corp's massive factory in Shanghai, China, which assembles iPhones for Apple.[CN]

为苹果公司组装iPhone手机的和硕联合集团上海大规模工厂内部情形罕见曝光

Workers line up with military precision to have their ID badges scanned on an iPad by a supervisor during roll call.[CN]

点名时,工人们整齐列队,管理者用iPad扫描他们的工牌。

They then make their way in single file to the assembly line where they undergo facial recognition checks to clock in.[CN]

然后他们鱼贯而入(/in single file:排成纵队,鱼贯/),走向装配线,这里他们被要求做面部识别检查,打卡上班(/clock in:打卡上班/)。

Companies granted access to Western media for the first time after facing accusations staff worked gruelling hours.[CN]

在遭到要求工人超负荷工作的指控后,公司首次同意西方媒体的访问。

33839E9300000578-0-image-m-3_1461574147078.jpg

Military efficiency: Hundreds of workers line up for roll call at the Pegatron factory in Shanghai, China, which makes iPhones for Apple[CN]

军队的效率:数百名工人排队点名(/roll call:点名/)

33839EFB00000578-0-image-a-4_1461574167074.jpg

Clocking in: A supervisor holds an  iPad as he checks an employee's badge during roll call at a Pegatron factory in Shanghai, China

Lined up with military precision, hundreds of employees wait to make iPhones at one of the most secretive factories in the Apple production line.[CN]

苹果产品线的一个最秘密的工厂,成百的职员像军队一样排着整齐的队伍,等待制作iPhone手机。

Dressed in pink jackets, blue hairnets and plastic slippers, the workers have their ID badges scanned on an iPad by a supervisor at morning roll call.[CN]

工人们穿着粉红色夹克,戴着蓝色发网,穿着塑料拖鞋,管理者用iPad扫描他们的工牌做早晨的点名。

From there, they make their way in single file to the assembly line but not before undergoing facial recognition checks at security turnstiles  to clock in.[CN]

从那里,他们排队走到装配线,但是在之前他们经过安全回转门时被要求做面部扫描检查,打卡上班。

Pegatron Corp employs up to 50,000 people to assemble iPhones at its plant in Shanghai which covers an area the size of 90 football fields.[CN]

该公司在上海的这个工厂雇佣了5万多iPhones装配员工,工厂面积有90个足球场大。

33839D4300000578-0-image-a-7_1461574219080.jpg

Keeping tabs: A supervisor scans staff into an iPad during the morning roll call before they head to the assembly line to make iPhones

3383A06000000578-0-image-a-8_1461574226550.jpg

A supervisor checks names of staff at the Pegatron factory, the secretive realm where the world's most profitable smartphones are made

3383A00600000578-0-image-a-16_1461574373074.jpg

Roll call: Pegatron and Apple have adopted new procedures to keep assemblers from doing excessive overtime after years of accusations

As they enter the compound, workers must pass through metal detectors designed to weed out any camera or video equipment that could be used to leak details of any unreleased technology.

They then climb up a stairwell that has a safety net draped across the middle – to prevent accidents or suicide attempts – before getting changed into their uniforms and lining up for roll call. 

Until now, the factory's inner workings have been a closely guarded secret.

But the two firms have, for the first time, allowed a western journalist  inside after facing years of accusations that their staff were having to work gruelling hours on low pay.

Jenny Chan, a lecturer at Oxford's Kellogg College, said: 'The fact they let a reporter in shows that they are responding to external pressure and trying to be more transparent. At least on the surface, they're trying to fix something.' 

According to China Labour Watch, base salaries are so low employees are forced to work overtime just to get by, with one employee revealing her salary was 2,020 yuan (£230) a month. An iPhone 6 in China costs 4,488 yuan (£480).

33839D0B00000578-3557310-image-a-40_1461574589875.jpg

Employees line up for roll call at the Pegatron Corp factory in Shanghai, China, before heading to the assembly line for the day's work

33839EC300000578-0-image-a-11_1461574304735.jpg

Off to work they go: The staff wear blue hair nets and plastic slippers as they make their way to the assembly area after roll call

33839F9100000578-0-image-a-13_1461574319756.jpg

Army of workers: As many as 50,000 people assemble iPhones at the factory which is part of Apple Inc's closely guarded supply chain

33839F6300000578-0-image-a-15_1461574356336.jpg

On the march: The workers follow arrows on the floor and inspirational posters on the wall as they make their way to the assembly line

33839CE800000578-3557310-image-a-49_1461574668421.jpg

Punching in: Employees make their way towards the assembly line area where the world's most profitable smartphones are made for Apple

Giving a tour to the reporter from Bloomberg, the head of the facility John Sheu said the new ID system was introduced to improve efficiency, adding that 'every seconds counts.'

But he says it also allows the company to monitor when staff are working too many hours by sending managers automated messages if they near the 60-hour weekly limit or have clocked in six days in a row. 

Pegatron said it adheres to the Electronic Industry Citizenship Coalition's guidelines that cap overtime at roughly 80 hours a month, while Apple said its suppliers stick to the industry group's code of conduct.

The system also gives them a higher level of income transparency by letting staff check their hours, pay stubs and monthly lodging and food expenses at touchscreen terminals around the campus.

3383A1C800000578-0-image-a-24_1461574437200.jpg

An employee looks into a facial recognition device which registers workers when they enter the assembly line area at the Pegatron factory

3383A1CC00000578-0-image-a-21_1461574413414.jpg

Staff look into facial recognition devices as they swipe their badges to enter the assembly line area at the Pegatron factory in Shanghai

3383A17800000578-0-image-a-22_1461574419391.jpg

Time for work: Employees walk through turnstiles to enter the assembly line area at the Pegatron Corp factory in Shanghai, China

33839D6B00000578-0-image-a-28_1461574482160.jpg

The factory is one of the most secretive facilities in the iPhone production line and covers an area equal to almost 90 football fields

3383A13800000578-0-image-a-27_1461574456560.jpg

An employee uses a facial recognition device as she swipes her badge to enter the assembly line area at the Pegatron Corp factory

Access to the factory comes a month after the family of a 26-year-old worker at the plant claimed he died after working up to 12 hours a day.

Tian Fulei was found dead on February 3 in a dormitory he shared with other workers near Shanghai at Pegatron.

A verdict of 'sudden death' was given in court, but no autopsy was carried out.

Mr Tian's family said he worked relentless overtime hours at Pegatron and his death came less than two months after an undercover BBC Panorama investigation revealed how workers there worked to the point of collapse. 

His sister, Tian Zhoumei, 25, told MailOnline that her brother had been healthy up until his death and blamed overworking for his demise.

Pegatron has denied a link between the death and his working environment. 

The death of Mr Tian once again highlights concerns over the working conditions of lowly-paid workers feeding the world's demands for Apple's products.

The company announced it had made the largest quarterly profit in corporate history in January, posting £11.8bn in its fiscal first quarter. More than 74.5 million iPhones were sold worldwide in the three months leading to December 27 last year.

The Tian family were given 80,000 Yuan (£8,300) as a 'gesture' from Pegatron – an amount upped from 15,000 Yuan (£1,500) after police aided negotiations. 

The statement read: 'Worker safety and well-being are our top priorities and we work hard to make sure every Pegatron facility provides a healthy work environment for our workers. 

'We are deeply saddened by the loss of Tian Fulei who worked with us as a visual inspector on the assembly line in our Shanghai facility.

'We investigated the circumstances of this case immediately, finding no link to the work environment. We provided support and assistance to the Tian family and our thoughts remain with them at this difficult time.' 

A spokesperson for Apple's Supplier Responsibility department said the company would look into the death-related claims but refused to comment directly on them. 

33839D0300000578-3557310-image-a-37_1461574565261.jpg

Industrial: An employee changes into his uniform at his locker before heading to the morning roll call

3383A0AC00000578-3557310-image-a-30_1461574525195.jpg

Staff walk past rows of lockers. Pegatron says it adopted the new ID system to create an efficient and responsible working environment'

3383A02600000578-3557310-image-a-33_1461574535245.jpg

More like an airport: Employees sit at an employee service centre inside the Pegatron Corp factory in Shanghai, China

3383A02F00000578-3557310-image-a-35_1461574541911.jpg

Employees look at their smartphones while sitting at an employee service centre inside the Pegatron Corp factory in Shanghai, China

3383A07000000578-3557310-image-a-44_1461574625494.jpg

Employees check their pay stubs on computer terminals at an employee service centre inside the Pegatron Corp factory in Shanghai

3383A09800000578-3557310-image-a-46_1461574634624.jpg

Downtime: An employee buys two sausage sticks during his lunch break in the factory canteen

3383A04E00000578-3557310-image-a-43_1461574608383.jpg

Pictures of employees hang on a wall at an employee service centre inside a Pegatron Corp factory in Shanghai, China

国外网友评论 0人跟帖    20924人参与

UpNorth

It looks so depressing.[CN]

看起来令人沮丧。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
CrakeReply toUpNorth

Not entirely sure how factory work can look any different..[CN]

不完全确定工厂的工作看上去有何不同。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Scotty MacReply toUpNorth

There are over 800,000 people working in state of the art factories in various key areas in China that owners must comply with China laws. The government sets the compensation rate not the factory. Foxconn is also opening up a large plant in India to get ashes to very cheap labour. I do not hear anyone talking about that as yet.[CN]

在中国,有超过80万人工作在几个关键领域的这种技术型工厂,经营者必须遵守中国的法律。政府给予一定比率的补贴。富士康也正在印度开设大型工厂,使用那里的廉价劳动力。我还没听到有人谈论这些。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
JBReply toUpNorth

Chinese are used to that sort of regimentation[CN]

中国人习惯了这种制度。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
tommyReply toUpNorth

Appart from the privalaged few. Are we all going to end up like this one day? Because if we are its best to get your heads out of the TV and do something.[CN]

除了少数特权外,我们都将每天像这样结束一天吗?要是这样,我们最好停止看电视,行动起来,做点事情。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
DeputyReply toUpNorth

It's a clean, modern factory that pays above the local wage for equivalent jobs that also follows recognised safety and working hours. If that is depressing UpNorth, maybe you should visit some more factories that are not as good - in this country![CN]

这个工厂干净、现代化,支付高于当地水平的薪水,有有保障的安全环境和工作时间。如果是这让UpNorth感到沮丧,或许你应该去看看这个国家更糟糕的一些工厂。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Unipower GTReply toUpNorth

As they work they can hum Kraftwerks, The Robots. .... " we are programmed just to do anything you want us to, we are the robots, we are the robots, we are the robots, we are the robots"[CN]

他们工作时,能像机器人样嗡嗡,“我们被编程了,要我们做什么就做什么,我们是机器人,我们是机器人 ... ...”

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Kraven1Reply toUpNorth
Food at the canteen, is at Apple prices. Leftist consumerism, fed by communism. (Most lefties, use Apple garbage).
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Dr. BogusReply toUpNorth

Be happy in your work... I hope this gives all you trendy hipsters a guilt-trip.[CN]

你的工作很舒心吧 ... 我希望这些让你们这些嬉皮士愧疚。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
IrisheyesReply toUpNorth
WHILE THE FAT CATS OFF APPLE SWAN AROUND THEIR LUXURY MANSIONS AND PRIVATE JETS ... SCARY WHATS HAPPENING TO THE WORLD
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
SteveReply toUpNorth

Get someone to photograph white collar work in the UK. See how depressing that looks.[CN]

让人拍拍英国白领的工作,看看那是怎样地让人沮丧。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
iSayReply toUpNorth

Dr Bogus take some acid and chill.[CN]

酸儒。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
DeputyReply toUpNorth

Not quite sure how you can link salaries to final product cost as a negative thing? I used to work building nuclear submarines, they cost £1.3 billion and my salary was only £450 per week.....[CN]

把工资和最终产品的价值来比较,而否定某些事情不合适吧?我曾经参与建造核潜艇,它们要13亿英镑,而我的工资才一周450英镑 ... ...

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
WarriorOfTheNetReply toUpNorth

Yes, they are used to it because they are raised that way. However it looks very depressing and to be honest they look like worker ants all lined up like robots. It's a tough life. No employee should be treated like this. It is very sad indeed.[CN]

是的,他们习惯了,因为他们那样谋生。然而还是让人沮丧,他们看起来像忠实的工蚁,像机器人排着队。生活很艰辛。没有员工像这样被对待,真的很伤心。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
DaveResnamReply toUpNorth

They are there to work not faff about and send their "hilarious" pranks to YouTube. That's why we failed as an industrial nation. Too much worker power. These Chinese my look serious here but I'm sure they probably have a lot of fun outside work.[CN]

他们在那里是来工作的,不是瞎忙活,不是为了向YouTube发送他们的滑稽闹剧作品。这就是为什么我们是个失败的工业国家,工人要求太多的权利。这些中国人在这里看起来很严肃,但是我确信,他们工作之外有很多乐趣。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
PatacakeReply toUpNorth

But otherwise, if it was fifty years ago, they would be working out in the ricefields, which would be worse. Wait until they get their first Unionists, Chartists, Co-operative movement and see the change for these workers or their descendants. It will take time, but will inevitably happen.[CN]

否则,要是50年前,他们还在稻田里劳作,更加糟糕。等着瞧到他们建立工会、要求权利的时候,再看这些工人或者他们子孙的变化。迟早会发生的,只是时间问题。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
The DonReply toUpNorth

iSlaves[CN]

iPhones

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
KissandtellReply toUpNorth

Apple is an American company so how many factories are there in the USA. That's right globalization.[CN]

苹果是美国公司,在美国有多少工厂呢。这就是全球化。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
JesiePReply toUpNorth

DaveResnam, or maybe that's why so many of them top themselves in these factories, but hey, at least it keeps the price of an iPhone down.[CN]

DaveResnam,或许这就是为什么这么多人待在这些工厂,但是至少能保持iPhone低价。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
riposteReply toUpNorth
Yep , the vile apple-fruit phones are made with cheap labour , in vile china , and then the vile apple-fruit company dodges taxes .
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
weAll - iNothingReply toUpNorth

They look like they wished they'd never woke up.[CN]

他们看起来他们希望他们从来不要醒来。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
HANG DOGReply toUpNorth

not really like their happy adverts eh[CN]

呃,真不像他们欢乐的广告。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Peter StephensonReply toUpNorth

What factory doesn't?[CN]

什么工厂不这样?

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
OVER HERE

So the iPhone is not made by children in a sweatshop after all?[CN]

原来iPhone根本不是在血汗工厂由孩子们制造的啊?

[ 1 ] [ 0 ]
The99percentReply toOVER HERE
I know, disgusting isn't it. I'm sending mine back
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Del BhoyReply toOVER HERE
this is just one of many factories I'm sure
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
IanReply toOVER HERE
Well, hi tech is usually not produced in sweatshop by children. But it is entirely down to your definition. If by "sweatshop" you mean appalling slave-like working conditions, the production line for Apple products with Foxconn, or as it is in this story, Pegatron, is a sweatshop. But feel free to enjoy your over-priced product manufactured by people paid a pittance.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Scotty MacReply toOVER HERE
If you use child labour in China you are in big trouble, and will be arrested unlike, India, Bangladesh, Vietnam, Cambodia. There is a labour shortage in China and cost of doing business has gone up significantly as labour intensive factories have been leaving China for many years and high tech and leading edge technology has taken its place.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Mors MagneReply toOVER HERE
Don't be disingenuous - it looks like something from a dystopian novel, such as 1984 or Brave New World.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
DeletemyaccountReply toOVER HERE
still is slavery for a stupid product that some will only buy to boil it and show that on youtube
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
riposteReply toOVER HERE
The vile china , which murders the animals and imprisons the tibetans , is a true ' same-sex partner ' of the apple-fruit company , which didn't cooperate with their own authorities to unlock one of their precious phones .
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
RosickyPerthReply toOVER HERE
human robots
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
jelletReply toOVER HERE
Noir is made by teenagers and young adults who probably make 50cents an hour, does that make you feel better...
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
barnsley tyke
The House of lords should be run like this no sloping of early.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Chris AllenReply tobarnsley tyke
And the houses of parliament as well. MW, no expenses and no bar or entertainment facilities.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
pdcReply tobarnsley tyke
'Sloping'? Are you Jeremy Clarkson?
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
MyTwoCents28Reply tobarnsley tyke
Aye!
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
guy1072
Modern slavery.....
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
fedup2Reply toguy1072
Coming soon to the UK!
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Say What You ThinkReply toguy1072
How is it ? They're paid to work there?
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
bushmaster80Reply toguy1072
Just what I thought. Have we come that far since the ancient world when thousands would or back-breaking labourers would create empires and/or wealth for a few individuals? "The strong do what they can; the weak suffer what they must" (Thucydides)
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Scotty MacReply toguy1072
Yes, slavery will come to the UK if you don't VOTE OUT.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
dickytReply toguy1072
just what Obama wants for us !
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
OliReply toguy1072
Really Scotty? What are your reasons for saying that? Where's the evidence? Lets see it, chop chop.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
max londonReply toguy1072
Am proud to say I don't, nor have ever, owned an i anything.... i is overated
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
riposteReply toguy1072
Too Close with vileness , to cooperate with suppression , whilst refusing to cooperate with yank authorities to unlock a frothy one's phone .
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
DeputyReply toguy1072
@max_london. You're almost guaranteed to have something else made by Pegatron. They also make for dozens of other companies.....
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Mustafa Leak
isn't communism great, workers kept under the thumb, while the masters live it up.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
dbunkReply toMustafa Leak
UK in the absence of a unionised workforce.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
FoxReply toMustafa Leak
Got too be honest Mustafa, Isn't capitalism the same.. Having worked in many UK Factories the people are still working to provide for the bosses lifesyles. It's the same Sh&t with a different label
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Scotty MacReply toMustafa Leak
Workers are not kept under the thumb. It is supply and demand, and there is a Labour shortage in China now as costs increase.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
frootyReply toMustafa Leak
Not surprised there's a labour shortage. Who'd want to work in what looks like a prison camp?
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
well.....Reply toMustafa Leak
so that people can walk down the street and not look where they are going......
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Beau LocksReply toMustafa Leak
Coming to Europe as we speak.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
silverjoyReply toMustafa Leak
Totally agree Fox. I worked (briefly) in a US bank with a lot of Chinese staff - it was exactly the same!
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
riposteReply toMustafa Leak
And the vile apple-fruit company is a willing participants with china in a totally nasty vileness .
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Edward MarloweReply toMustafa Leak
Never happen in the UK. Thatcher saw to that when she destoryed manufacturing industry here.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
wmhReply toMustafa Leak
Actually it's capitalism.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
cumbria boy
Not one happy looking face ?
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
manix3Reply tocumbria boy
There was one lad at lunchtime in the canteen:-)
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Leviathan22Reply tocumbria boy
would you be cheerful working in that prison camp?
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Say What You ThinkReply tocumbria boy
Who is happy going into work?
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
miker7Reply tocumbria boy
The facial recognition may not 'do' happy faces just like our passport photos.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
dickytReply tocumbria boy
DM specializes in 'sad' faces
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
MollayoReply tocumbria boy
Your wide smile to all the bosses at the office in London just for promotion must hurt your face.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
dude101Reply tocumbria boy
The dude with the sausage sticks look kinda happy.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
kv10
soon those devices will be in the hands of social justice warriors so they can write their "capitalism is bad" blogs
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Being taken 4 foolsReply tokv10
This is the model the EU has in mind for Europe........
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Edward MarloweReply tokv10
What you're seeing in those photos is capitalism at its purist. You appear to think that's bad...
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
vocem meam auditReply tokv10
this is capitalism.... apple are a sucessful american company.... capitalism always needs slaves or resources to take......these people are being exploited by capitalism like chickens in a battery farm or workers in an office block..... of course communism has its awful qualities too.....next AI will tell humans what to do
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Wings Of Redemption
Orwellian nightmare.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
riposteReply toWings Of Redemption
Also the E.U. is another Orwellian nightmare ; hopefully Brexit .
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
man city fan7777
They work 8 hours days same as me
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Detonator501Reply toman city fan7777
And you support Man City, I imagine they're happier to be honest.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
JoeLondonReply toman city fan7777
That is when they are not launching any new products..... 24/7 when they are about the launch any new iphones.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Bill SaundersReply toman city fan7777
I read 12 hours a day up to 60 a week is norm ??
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
The Non Profit
more robot than human.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
riposteReply toThe Non Profit
Yep , Robot , just like the E.U. bureaucrats ; vote Brexit .
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
paul
Just a large prison
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Reginald BarringtonReply topaul
That pays you to be there and you can leave at any time you want.....
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
OVER HEREReply topaul
Spoken like a real benefits leech who thinks work is slavery.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
itsyersel
Apple would be no where without these slaves
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
WLP002Reply toitsyersel
And the people who support them by buying the claptrap they produce.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
AJ
Collective sad face rating - 8/10
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
lollaReply toAJ
I'm afraid to say that these people are justifiably sad. They didn't get excluded for a bad haircut, or find a toenail in their burger.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Annie Rection
Cheap human robots.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Captain Blighty
This country had factory workers once, now we have millions on the dole and we import most of our factory made goods from China. When are we going to do something about it?
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
annaReply toCaptain Blighty
We used to have factories too
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Rufus McDufus
For those criticising, thanks to the likes of Apple average wages in China have increased ten times in the last decade.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
BostonPancakeReply toRufus McDufus
Apple fanboy
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Gabby747Reply toRufus McDufus
Samsung S L U T
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
El Barto
Apple has $178 billion in the bank, yet puts its phones together with partners that use something akin to slave-labour. By buying these products, you're participating in the exploitation of these people from a company that could clearly afford to choose to use more ethical standards. So much for its supposed West-Coast "hippie" values - Apple has become "the man", a ruthless capitalist company masquerading as alternative and "cool".
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
cushVFL
Even the more reason not to buy Apple.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
rusholme ruffian
Not one smile. How sad.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
DiggityReply torusholme ruffian
I think that you would be hard pushed to find somebody smiling in our factories either.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Sportspundito
Apple's slave camp. Terrible really!
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]

页面


评论

游客 请登录 注册