Biggest explosion in documented history is STILL a mystery: New study fails to find cause of 1908 Tunguska blast that 'split the sky in two' and flattened 80 million Siberian trees

史上最大爆炸仍谜云重重
Cheyenne Macdonald For Dailymail.com

The explosion occurred on June 30, 1908 in the Tunguska region of Siberia [CN]

1908年6月30号,西伯利亚通古斯卡地区发生大爆炸。

Eighty million trees flattened in blast, charred reindeer found by hundreds[CN]

8千万颗树在爆炸中被摧倒夷平,上百只驯鹿烧成焦炭。

Eyewitnesses at the time said it was as though the sky was split in two[CN]

当时的目击者宣称天空似乎被劈成两半。

Scientists say it was likely a comet or asteroid, though little evidence found[CN]

科学家宣称可能是彗星或者小行星撞击产生的,尽管证据几乎无迹可寻。

Others have suggested UFOs, supernatural activity, or the curse of a god[CN]

其他人则说有可能是不明飞行物,超自然的现象,或者是上帝的诅咒。

3614229E00000578-0-image-a-1_1467997444119.jpg

More than 100 years ago, a massive explosion ripped through the sky over the Tunguska region of Siberia, flattening trees nearly 31 miles around. From UFO theories to speculation about the supernatural, the mysterious event has spurred explanations of all kinds[CN]

100多年前,西伯利亚通古斯卡地区,一次大爆炸划破天际,方圆约31英里的树木悉数被撂倒。从不明飞行物到各种超自然力量的揣测,这次谜之事件引发了各种解说。

3614224F00000578-3681264-image-a-1_1467999655564.jpg

3614227D00000578-3681264-image-a-2_1467999655594.jpg

With no impact crater and little evidence of such an object ever found, scientists remain perplexed as to what truly caused the event in which 'the sky was split in two.' The affected area is pictured in 2008, left, and during an Russian expedition decades earlier[CN]

没有陨石坑,实物也无迹可寻。科学家们仍是疑窦重重,究竟是什么引发了此次爆炸,将天空划分成两半。图片摄于2008年的事发地带(左图),早在几十年前俄国探险队到过此处。

3614222C00000578-0-image-a-24_1467997839663.jpg

The blast is thought to have been produced by a comet or asteroid hurtling through Earth's atmosphere at over 33,500 miles per hour, resulting in an explosion equal to 185 Hiroshima bombs as pressure and heat rapidly increased[CN]

此次爆炸普遍认为是彗星或小行星以每小时超过33,500英里的速度撞击地球大气层造成的。随着压力和热量的急剧增加,导致了等同于185颗原子弹的大爆炸。

3614225C00000578-0-image-a-11_1467997594465.jpg

The possibility of an asteroid explosion was first proposed in 1927 by Leonid Kulik, 20 years after the event. A 1938 image from Kulik's investigations is shown above

3614228F00000578-3681264-image-m-26_1467998152213.jpg

361422AC00000578-3681264-image-a-27_1467998159314.jpg

Eighty million trees had been laid flat in the blast, and the charred carcasses of reindeer were found by the hundreds. The area is shown in 1908, left, and 1938, right, where a tree can be seen with the top half shorn off from the explosion

3614B10C00000578-0-image-a-25_1467997884997.jpg

Numerous studies have attempted to make sense of what happened on June 30, 1908 at Tunguska, a remote region with long, hostile winters and short summers that render the environment an uninhabitable swamp

More than 100 years ago, a massive explosion ripped through the sky over the Tunguska region of Siberia, flattening trees nearly 31 miles around.

The blast is thought to have been produced by a comet or asteroid hurtling through Earth's atmosphere at over 33,500 miles per hour, resulting in an explosion equal to 185 Hiroshima bombs as pressure and heat rapidly increased.

But, with no impact crater and little evidence of such an object ever found, scientists remain perplexed as to what truly caused the event in which 'the sky was split in two' - and a new study has failed to reach a conclusion.

Numerous studies have attempted to make sense of what happened on June 30, 1908 at Tunguska.

This is a remote region with long, hostile winters and short summers that render the environment an uninhabitable swamp, according to BBC.

From UFO theories to speculation about the supernatural, the mysterious event has spurred explanations of all kinds, many of them lacking scientific basis.

Some scientists even suggested a black hole had collided with Earth – but other experts quickly shot down the idea.

On the 100 year anniversary of the explosion, Don Yeomans of Nasa's Near-Earth Object Office at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory explained that the locals believed the event marked the visitation of the god Ogdy, who they feared had cursed the area.

Eighty million trees had been laid flat in the blast, and the charred carcasses of reindeer were found by the hundreds.

In a review published this year in the Annual Review of Earth and Planetary Sciences, Natalia Artemieva of the Planetary Science Institute in Tucson, Arizona explains that the event followed a clear course.

The object likely entered the atmosphere at 9-19 miles per second, and would have been extremely fragile, destroying itself roughly six miles above Earth.

Any remaining traces would be cosmic dust, BBC explains, making them extremely difficult, as they could be just a millimetre in size.

The blast sent shock waves as far away as England, and even people in Asia saw the sky glowing until midnight – bright enough to read a newspaper outdoors.

'Suddenly in the north sky…the sky was split in two, and high above the forest the whole northern part of the sky appeared covered with fire,' recalled an eyewitness, who was thrown from his chair by the heat blast 40 miles from the site of the explosion.

'At that moment there was a bang in the sky and a mighty crash…The crash was followed by a noise like stones falling from the sky, or of guns firing. The earth trembled.'

The possibility of an asteroid explosion was first proposed in 1927 by Leonid Kulik, 20 years after the event.

Others suggested the space-object may instead have been a comet, made up of ice rather than rock, meaning it would have evaporated as it entered Earth's atmosphere.

Later investigations revealed small traces of silicate and magnetite in the soil, which were found to be high in nickel.

This analysis pointed toward the explanation of a meteoroid of asteroid origin, according to BBC, which annihilated itself as it plunged through Earth's atmosphere.

More recent studies, including one in 2013, confirm that rock samples found in the area are in fact of meteoric origin with traces of a carbon mineral called lonsdaleite, which is known to form when meteorites crash into Earth.

But, some scientists warn that these findings do not definitively explain the bizarre explosion – with meteor showers being a frequent occurrence, these samples could be the remnants of a much smaller, unnoticed event.

In 2007, a team of Italian scientists proposed that Siberia's Lake Cheko is actually the impact crater from the object, as it was not on any maps prior to this event.

This explanation, too, is unpopular among scientists,  Artemieva explained to BBC, as the lake is shallow enough to recover any remnants that would exist.

To some degree, the Tunguska event still remains a mystery, which scientists are continually working to solve – but, whether it be from a comet or asteroid, most agree that the explosion was caused by a large cosmic body slamming into Earth's atmosphere.

国外网友评论 0人跟帖    7710人参与

Mr Make U Think

'Scientists' need to look at volcanos that were erupting in 1908. Google shows Mt Vesuvius erupted in 1908, firing rocks into space (which has been documented) and these often fall back as meteorites, damaging the Earth and making 'shooting stars' and comets. It is a simple explanation and evidence is mounting (meteorites are made out of the same stuff as Earth rocks - how else can that be explained?) #MakeUThink[CN]

科学家们得好好去考察1908年爆发的火山。谷歌显示,维苏威火山1908年爆发,岩石射向天空(有文件记载)这些岩石变成陨石返回破坏地球,成了“有攻击性的外星来物”和彗星。很简单的说明,证据确凿(陨石和地球的陨石有相同的物质组成 - 不然还能怎么解释?)

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
BroadsidesReply toMr Make U Think

You training to do stand up? Or are you a nut job?[CN]

你是刚学走路吗?还是说你就是一傻蛋?

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
CountrylassReply toMr Make U Think

You make me ashamed to say I went to school in Truro.[CN]

我都不好意思说了,我在Truro上学。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Peter .Reply toMr Make U Think

Big Nugget is still obsessed with volcanos, I see. (And stop denying you're BG, you lying toad.))[CN]

大傻冒真的很痴迷于火山啊。我懂了。(不用否认了,你就是BG,谎话连篇的癞蛤蟆)

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Crossx77Reply toMr Make U Think

You really are thick LOL,[CN]

你还真逗,哈哈哈

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Norm De PlumeReply toMr Make U Think

Why don't you make something up and run with it? See who goes along with you...[CN]

为什么不自己编些东西,自圆其说呢?看看有多少人支持你...

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Peter .Reply toMr Make U Think

..Forgot to add, Big Nugget, everything you've said is pure invention as well. Volcanos putting rocks in space, goodness, it really take a scientific ignoramus to invent that one![CN]

忘记说一点了,大傻瓜,你所说的纯粹虚构。火山把岩石喷向太空,天呐,只有没有科学常识的人才能说出这种话吧!

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Mr Make U ThinkReply toMr Make U Think

Peter, hello. Do you have evidence? I do #MakeULearn[CN]

你好啊,Peter.你有证据吗?我有哦。#MakeULearn

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
The DocReply toMr Make U Think

Documented by whom? Show me evidence of a volcano ejecting matter at a speed and force to go high enough to get to Siberia under Earth conditions.[CN]

谁记录在案的?给我看看证据,在地球的条件下,火山喷发的速度能射到这么高,能飞到西伯利亚。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
ScepticalScot

The Kippers will blame the EU for aggression against Mother Russia.[CN]

小喽啰们会指责欧盟又去侵犯俄罗斯领土的。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
GoodbyeSlipperyDaveReply toScepticalScot

We're all kippers now friend, and like it or not, that includes you..[CN]

朋友,我们现在都是小喽啰,不管你喜不喜欢,你也是其中之一。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
ScepticalScotReply toScepticalScot

We all maybe Outers but never a Kipper.[CN]

我们可能袖手旁观,但绝不是小喽啰。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Paul_Xavier_GreenReply toScepticalScot

Cuckoo....!!!! :-)[CN]

咯咯咯:-)

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
ScepticalScotReply toScepticalScot

@Paul suits you sir[CN]

@Paul 挺适合你的嘛

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
RollingTMansg

Do you know why dinosaur were wiped out?? Because they didn't believed in God.[CN]

知道为什么恐龙灭绝了吗?因为它们不信上帝。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Peter .Reply toRollingTMansg

Oh grow up, for goodness' sake. Bloody trolls. Worse than gnats... (Twice as stupid, too.)[CN]

看在上帝份上,成熟点吧。天杀的黑子!比小蚊子还更讨厌(也蠢上一倍)

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
RollingTMansgReply toRollingTMansg

You cant argue with facts. All other race been wiped out only us human remain, and it wasn't a coincidence that zero city been hit.[CN]

事实胜于雄辩。其他种族都灭绝了,只有人类存活下来。没有城市遭遇攻击也绝不是偶然。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Crossx77Reply toRollingTMansg

How do you know, have you spoken to a dinosaur and asked them?[CN]

你怎么知道的?你跟恐龙谈过,问过它们?

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
RollingTMansgReply toRollingTMansg

Like i have already said before, the facts are undisputable. Facts are fact![CN]

我说过,事实是不可辩驳的。事实就是事实。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
rooobyReply toRollingTMansg

Great joke, if it is one.[CN]

这笑话不错,如果你真在说笑的话。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
OrinocoReply toRollingTMansg

Have you forgotten to take your medicine again???[CN]

你是不是又忘记吃药了?

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
The DocReply toRollingTMansg

My cat doesn't believe in God. Why is he (and his species) allowed to continue? I've certainly never seen him praying.[CN]

我的猫不信上帝啊。为什么他(和他的物种)还能延续呢?我可没见过他做祷告。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
King Henry VI

It can only be the work of All'ah. We should not question his work but instead admire it.[CN]

只能是真主的杰作。我们不该质疑,而该去敬畏。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Sw5misterReply toKing Henry VI

And get on our knees 4 x a day to pray[CN]

然后一天跪4次来祷告。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
ChrisReply toKing Henry VI

And pray to a god that doesn't exist[CN]

向根本不存在的上帝祷告

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
daredevilReply toKing Henry VI

U must b hallucinating bro.... The greatest religion is humanity...there is no ala[CN]

哥们,你又产生幻觉了吧?最好的教义是人性…根本就没有什么真主….

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
DaveCReply toKing Henry VI

big explosion, kind of fitting really[CN]

大爆炸,这理论说得通。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
dgladysReply toKing Henry VI

Understand it first then marvel at the beauty All'ah has hidden within for you to find - or is that part of All'ah's work somehow off limits?.[CN]

你先去理解,然后赞赏他的魅力,阿拉时刻在你身边,等待你发现 – 或者那真主的杰作超出了理解范围?

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
TheScarlettMissReply toKing Henry VI

It was the work of Nikola Tesla actually but whatever...[CN]

事实上是Nikola Tesla,但随便吧…

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
TheScarlettMissReply toKing Henry VI

All gods are lies.[CN]

所有鬼神都是扯淡。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Jimmy

Why can't it just be left unexplained,why do we have to try and find an answer to everything,maybe whatever did happen was beyond our comprehension.[CN]

为什么就不能留着,不加解释呢?为什么我们一定得试图找出所有事情的答案呢,或许这事早就超出我们的理解范围呢?

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
PtahReply toJimmy

So if it happens again, we can be prepared and do something about it. Survival is bliss![CN]

这样一来事情再度发生时,我们可以未雨绸缪,有备无患。活着就是福气。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
eloracbmulpReply toJimmy

Buffoon.[CN]

小丑一个

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
JimmyjimsReply toJimmy

A bit like your birth[CN]

生来就是吧

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
dgladysReply toJimmy

It may be forever beyond your comprehension but not everyone is as stupid as that. They would probably need help standing up.[CN]

你可能永远理解不了,但不是每个人都像你这么蠢。他们站起来可能都需要人扶。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
amrad

During the cold war Americans accidently launched a nuclear missile towards Russia, to save the planet from destruction and world war three Aliens made the missile go through a worm hole in time and the missile landed in Russia in 1908.[CN]

冷战期间美国不小心向俄国发射了核导弹,为了拯救地球免于毁灭和第三次大战,外星人让导弹及时穿过虫洞,1908年导弹在俄国着陆。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
FreshWhyteReply toamrad

can I buy some pot from you ?[CN]

能从你这买个故事版权不?

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
TootyManReply toamrad

World war 3 was meant to start two weeks ago according to Cameron[CN]

据卡梅伦的说法,第三次世界大战两周前就开打了

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Peter .Reply toamrad

To save the world from destruction they sent it back to the world? Clever, those aliens..[CN]

为了避免地球免受其害,又把导弹送回这个世界?这些外星人也真够聪明的。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
TootyManReply toamrad

W w 3 should have started two weeks ago according to Cameron[CN]

据卡梅伦的说法,第三次世界大战两周前就开打了

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
IamJohnGaltReply toamrad

When you shake the bottle in hear silence it means you're out of medication[CN]

你摇摇瓶子听不到声音,说明你又得买药吃了。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
BirchyReply toamrad

WW3 did start two weeks ago in Cameron's teacup. It ended when he washed it out.[CN]

卡梅伦茶后说法是,第三次世界大战两周前的确开打了。他改变想法后就又结束了。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
UsOcoReply toamrad

You are off to a good start but you need to add some filler to your story. It is a little short.[CN]

开头变的不错,但是还得加些猛料啊。故事有点短了。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Portlandia

I think curse of God is the most likely cause. Seriously.[CN]

我想上帝的诅咒可能是最大成因。我是认真的。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
PaulbReply toPortlandia

There had to be a religious nut commenting on here somewhere![CN]

总有宗教狂热分子到处评论。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
JohnReply toPortlandia

Seriously? Then you need a little education.[CN]

你说真的?你还得读点书啊。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
LeeWReply toPortlandia

So would that be Thor the dude with the huge war hammer? Yahweh was more into drowning the crp out of people.[CN]

是那个使大锤的雷神索尔干的吗?耶和华(北欧的雷神)更喜欢对人类干这事吧。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
HeyHo5Reply toPortlandia

Why, what had the reindeer done to upset God?[CN]

为什么,驯鹿做了什么得罪了上帝?

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Markkit

Seriously daily mail?? This got figured out years ago[CN]

《每日速递》说的是真的吗?那事很多年前就搞清楚了啊

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
rikki_doxx

Maybe an underground volcanic explosion??[CN]

或许是地底火山爆发?

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Peter .Reply torikki_doxx

Maybe think. (What's an underground volcanic explosion?)[CN]

这个或许…(地底火山爆发又是什么鬼?)

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
GetoffmylawnReply torikki_doxx

I think that's an intriguing new perspective there, rikki. Not from above, but from within. Supposing, for example, a violent volcanic eruption from deep in crust, burst up through some vein or strata of low resistance, accelerates to a high speed, and then strikes a large hard mantle of rock that it can't fully penetrate. I have no idea what the local geology of that area is, and I am fully talking out of my hat, but still, there may be as many, or more, plausible explanations from below as there are from above.[CN]

我觉得这提供了一个有深度的新角度,rikki。并非来自上空,而是来自于地球内部。假设,举个例子,地壳深处,凶猛的火山爆发,冲破薄弱的地质表层,达到一个极高的速度,去冲击巨大而坚实、无法穿透的地幔上的岩石。我不知道当地的地质怎么样,但我敢断言,还会有很多,甚至更多的合理解释,说明有来自地球外部的力量,就有来自内部的。

[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Peter .Reply torikki_doxx
Some volcanoes release magma, like K¿lauea, without much drama. Others do indeed explode because the magma contains contains dissolved gases under immense pressure. That pressure is only released at or near the surface, when the magma explodes like champagne when the cork is released. There are no underground explosions as the pressure is contained.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
dgladysReply torikki_doxx
Ooooh yes! volcanic explosion! One that doeesn't leave a stuffing big hole in the ground or loads of lava solidified on the surface and certainly no huge pile of ash.Can you tie shoelaces?
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Mr. CommonSense
My gret great granddad caused it.......he farted
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Winch25
It was probably caused by soviet bomb tests for bombs that they were planning to use to wipe out capitalism.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
LeeWReply toWinch25
The plan was shelved when someone came up with cultural Marxism and dropped it on American colleges, the fallout can be still felt today as once intelligent youngsters after exposure quickly mutate into mindless SJW's and snowflakes.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
ZabaMan
Probably Brexits fault
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Lord_James_of Luton
The Almighty, in his Infinite Wisdom, directed the asteroid so that it missed London....
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Dave
Actually my Grandfather was responsible for this. He was en-route Home from India, when he decided to make a detour and trek throught the region. Unfortunatley he was still suffering the after effects of all those Curry's. His last one (we never did see him again) was his last, and what a blast that was!
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
I want my
We must not question the bible but instead look up to it for guidance. #goddoesexist
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
TunaPieReply toI want my
whatever. I came to the comments section looking to laugh, not read stupid religious bull$h*t.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Joe Doe
Sounds like a near miss. Close enough to graze and cause damage but not close enough for impact, or debris to be left behind. Something big just whizzed by us. Almost hit us, but didn't. That would be my guess.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
FreshWhyteReply toJoe Doe
your theory makes no sense, in order for it to have any sort of effect on the ground it would have had to enter the atmosphere, once its in the atmosphere it ain't getting out, gravity pulls it to the ground.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Paulqx
BREXIT caused it.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Chloe-e
Fear god
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
dgladysReply toChloe-e
fear ignorance even more
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
FullersReply toChloe-e
Fear religion even more.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Chloe-eReply toChloe-e
What will you do when u are alone in ur grave and there is no one to save you and hear you ??who will save u? science? LOL
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Chloe-eReply toChloe-e
Fear your life after death this world is temporary
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Mark Polonach
Don't some people think it was that scientist sending electricity through the clouds or soemthing? Never forget that Russia at one stage had plans to build one nuclear device that could have basically cracked the planet in half, but some one with half a brain and a good heart over stopped it.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
WIthnailReply toMark Polonach
Yeah, that'll be it - "That scientist sending electricity through the clouds or something'. Clearly there is no other sensible explanation.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
ric-hReply toMark Polonach
The scientist was Noikola Tessla. The rumour is that he was able to send electricity through the air so people could access it for free. It was promptly covered up as there was no profit to be made - hence the existence today of the rapacious energy companies.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
ric-hReply toMark Polonach
Nikola Tesla. Sorry.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Denis BarreReply toMark Polonach
ric-h: "It was promptly covered up as there was no profit to be made". If this were true, don't you think someone would have re-discovered it by now? The US armed forces would LOVE to be able to do this! And why haven't they covered up those pesky solar cells, which generate power from SUNLIGHT, for Pete's sake?!
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
Whizzle
The same happened over Britain from Aberdeen to Cardiff and then on to Peru in 562 AD. It flattened castles, farm buildings and fused stone walls like Hadrain's Wall, possibly triggering volcanic eruptions and turned Britain into the sulphurous burnt out wasteland of Arthurian legend for 11 years, allowing the illiterate pagan Saxons to wander in virtually unchallenged until the British could redeploy their continental army.
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]
dgladysReply toWhizzle
Can you supply some references for that one? I'd like to read up
[ 0 ] [ 0 ]

评论

游客 请登录 注册